Morris Law is a Berkeley criminal defense law firm. Call (510) 350-3225 for a free case review of your murder case. Murder in California is governed by Penal Code §187 (murder) and §189 (degree definitions). All Berkeley cases route to the Alameda County courthouses in Downtown Oakland — the Wiley W. Manuel Courthouse for misdemeanors and the René C. Davidson Courthouse for felonies. Seth Morris spent years in both courthouses as a Deputy Public Defender.

What is murder under California law?

Berkeley Murder Lawyer — Morris Law

Under California Penal Code §187, murder is the unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought. Penal Code §189 divides murder into first-degree and second-degree offenses. First-degree murder covers killings that are premeditated, committed by lying in wait, poisoning, or during specific felonies like robbery or burglary. Second-degree murder covers any murder that is not first-degree. Voluntary manslaughter (Penal Code §192(a)) is an intentional killing without malice — often the result of heat of passion or imperfect self-defense. Involuntary manslaughter (Penal Code §192(b)) is an unintentional killing during a lawful act done without due caution.

Penalties for murder in California

Penalties for murder vary sharply by the specific statute, degree, and prior record. Below are the primary penalty ranges we see in Berkeley and Alameda County cases:

  • First-degree murder (PC §187): 25 years to life in state prison. Life without parole is available if a special circumstance under PC §190.2 applies (multiple murders, murder for financial gain, murder of a peace officer, etc.). Death penalty is legally available but California has a moratorium on executions.
  • Second-degree murder (PC §187): 15 years to life in state prison. 20 years to life if the killer shot from a vehicle. Doubled with a prior strike.
  • Voluntary manslaughter (PC §192(a)): 3, 6, or 11 years in state prison. Strike offense under PC §667.5(c).
  • Involuntary manslaughter (PC §192(b)): 2, 3, or 4 years in state prison.
  • Vehicular manslaughter (PC §192(c)): misdemeanor up to 1 year, or felony 16 months to 6 years. Gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated (PC §191.5) carries 4, 6, or 10 years.
  • Attempted murder (PC §664/187): premeditated attempt is life with parole; non-premeditated is 5, 7, or 9 years.
  • Firearm enhancement (PC §12022.53): personal discharge causing great bodily injury or death adds 25 years to life.

Collateral consequences often exceed the sentence itself — professional licensing, immigration status, firearm rights, and future employment can all be affected. We assess collateral exposure at the start of every case.

How Morris Law defends murder cases in Berkeley

Every case is different, but the defense strategies below are the ones that most often produce dismissals, reductions, and acquittals in murder cases:

  • Self-defense and defense of others (PC §197). An honest and reasonable belief in imminent danger of death or great bodily injury is a complete defense. California has no duty to retreat.
  • Imperfect self-defense. Under People v. Flannel, an honest but unreasonable belief in the need for deadly force reduces murder to voluntary manslaughter.
  • Heat of passion. Adequate provocation that would cause a reasonable person to act rashly reduces murder to voluntary manslaughter under PC §192(a).
  • Diminished actuality. Mental illness, intoxication, or trauma that negates the specific mental state required for first-degree murder can reduce the charge to second-degree.
  • Identification challenges. DNA, ballistics, eyewitness reliability, and surveillance footage are all attackable. We retain independent forensic experts and accident-reconstruction specialists.
  • SB 1437 resentencing (PC §1172.6). Anyone convicted of murder under the old felony-murder rule or natural-and-probable-consequences doctrine can petition for resentencing.
  • Fourth Amendment suppression (PC §1538.5). Evidence obtained through unlawful searches — cell phone data, home searches, DNA collection — can be excluded.

What to do if you are arrested for murder in Berkeley

Most Berkeley arrests are made by the Berkeley Police Department (BPD). UC Berkeley Police handle arrests on campus and in university housing. Alameda County Sheriff and CHP also make arrests. Take these steps:

  1. Invoke your right to counsel out loud. Under Miranda v. Arizona, you must clearly say you want a lawyer. Then stop talking. Anything you say — even something you think is exculpatory — can be used against you at trial.
  2. Do not consent to a search. Officers need a warrant, probable cause, or your consent to search. Refuse politely — refusal is not an admission.
  3. Call Morris Law at (510) 350-3225. We answer 24 hours a day. If you are in custody, have family call on your behalf.
  4. Preserve evidence. Photograph any injuries, torn clothing, or property damage. Note the arresting officers’ names, badge numbers, times, and witnesses.
  5. Stay off social media and jail phones. Both are recorded and admissible. Prosecutors and probation officers routinely review both.
  6. Write down your account for your attorney. Record what happened while events are fresh. Share only with counsel — that communication is privileged.

Why Berkeley residents choose Morris Law for murder defense

Morris Law was founded by Seth Morris, a former Alameda County Deputy Public Defender. Here is what we bring to every murder case:

  • Seth Morris was a Deputy Public Defender in Alameda County. He defended clients at the Wiley W. Manuel and René C. Davidson courthouses regularly — the same courthouses where every Berkeley case is heard. He knows the assigned judges, deputy district attorneys, and informal practices.
  • More than 25 jury trials, including life-in-prison exposure cases. When a case has to be tried, we know how to try it — from jury selection through closing argument.
  • Federal recognition on police body cameras and 4th Amendment litigation. Seth Morris helped develop the national Body Camera Toolkit through President Obama’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing. He has guest-lectured on the 4th Amendment at UC Berkeley for three years running.
  • Published in the Washington Post, Vanity Fair, and Salon. Interviewed on MSNBC’s The Last Word with Lawrence O’Donnell, NBC Bay Area, KQED, and KALW.
  • Berkeley office. Our office at 2025 Rose St #200 serves Berkeley, Albany, El Cerrito, Kensington, and Emeryville. Fast in-person meetings and rapid response to arrests.
  • 24/7 phone access. Arrests do not follow business hours. Someone answers at (510) 350-3225 around the clock.
  • Clear, plain-language updates. You will know what is happening at each stage without jargon.

Seth Morris is a member of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, California Attorneys for Criminal Justice, and the Alameda County Bar Association.

How murder cases move through Alameda County

Understanding the process helps clients make better decisions. Here is how a typical case moves through the Alameda County system:

Stage Where Timing
Arrest Berkeley — often by BPD Day 0
Booking Glenn E. Dyer or Santa Rita Jail Day 0–1
Arraignment Wiley W. Manuel or René C. Davidson Within 48 hours in custody
Preliminary hearing (felony) René C. Davidson Courthouse Within 10 court days in custody
Trial Wiley W. Manuel or René C. Davidson Within 60 days if not waived
Sentencing Same courthouse as trial Set by the court

Murder defense in Berkeley — Frequently Asked Questions

Where do Berkeley murder cases go to court?

Berkeley murder cases are heard at the René C. Davidson Courthouse (1225 Fallon St, Oakland), which handles all felony matters for Alameda County. Preliminary hearings, jury trials, and sentencing all take place there. Our attorneys appear at the Davidson Courthouse every week.

What is the difference between first-degree and second-degree murder in California?

First-degree murder (PC §189) requires premeditation, killing during specific felonies, or killing by torture, poison, or lying in wait — 25 years to life. Second-degree murder is any other murder with malice aforethought — 15 years to life. First-degree can add life without parole if a PC §190.2 special circumstance applies.

Did California abolish the felony-murder rule?

Largely, yes. Senate Bill 1437 (2019) amended PC §188 and §189. Now the defendant must either be the actual killer, have aided and abetted with intent to kill, or have been a major participant in the underlying felony with reckless indifference to human life. Many prior convictions are eligible for resentencing under PC §1172.6.

Can self-defense be a complete defense to murder in California?

Yes. Justifiable homicide under PC §197 — honest and reasonable belief in imminent danger of death or great bodily injury, with proportional force — is a complete defense and results in acquittal. California has no duty to retreat, and the castle doctrine (PC §198.5) presumes reasonable fear when an intruder forcibly enters your home.

What is voluntary manslaughter and when does it apply?

Voluntary manslaughter (PC §192(a)) is an intentional killing without malice — typically because of heat of passion from adequate provocation or an honest but unreasonable belief in the need for self-defense. It carries 3, 6, or 11 years instead of the 15-to-life or 25-to-life for murder.

Is the death penalty available for Berkeley murder cases?

Capital cases can still be charged, but Governor Newsom imposed a moratorium on executions in 2019, and California’s last execution was in 2006. The death-penalty designation effectively converts to LWOP in current practice, though it can affect plea negotiations and trial strategy.

Has Seth Morris tried murder cases?

Yes. Seth Morris has tried more than 25 jury trials, including cases where his clients faced life in prison. As a former Deputy Public Defender in Alameda County, he handled murder and attempted murder cases in the Wiley W. Manuel and René C. Davidson courthouses.

What should I do if my family member is arrested for murder in Berkeley?

Call (510) 350-3225 immediately. Do not let them speak with police, prosecutors, or investigators without a lawyer present. Do not discuss the case on jail phones — all calls are recorded and admissible. Do not post about the case on social media.

How long do murder cases take?

Murder cases typically take 12 to 24 months from arraignment to trial, sometimes longer. Preliminary hearing, motions practice, forensic testing, expert retention, and jury selection all take time. Speedy-trial rights can be asserted but often waived strategically to prepare a full defense.

Can a murder conviction be appealed?

Yes. Direct appeals raise trial errors and evidentiary rulings. Habeas corpus petitions raise ineffective assistance of counsel, new evidence, and constitutional violations. Post-conviction motions under PC §1172.6 (SB 1437 resentencing) apply to many older felony-murder convictions.

Get a free murder case review

Talk to a Berkeley criminal defense lawyer today. Call (510) 350-3225 or fill out our online form. Free case review. 24-hour phone. Berkeley office at 2025 Rose St #200.

Schedule Your Free Consultation

Related pages

Official government resources